You can not select more than 25 topics Topics must start with a letter or number, can include dashes ('-') and can be up to 35 characters long.

831 lines
32 KiB

6 months ago
# Copyright 2014 Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. All Rights Reserved.
#
# Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License"). You
# may not use this file except in compliance with the License. A copy of
# the License is located at
#
# http://aws.amazon.com/apache2.0/
#
# or in the "license" file accompanying this file. This file is
# distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF
# ANY KIND, either express or implied. See the License for the specific
# language governing permissions and limitations under the License.
"""Resolves regions and endpoints.
This module implements endpoint resolution, including resolving endpoints for a
given service and region and resolving the available endpoints for a service
in a specific AWS partition.
"""
import copy
import logging
import re
from enum import Enum
from botocore import UNSIGNED, xform_name
from botocore.auth import AUTH_TYPE_MAPS, HAS_CRT
from botocore.crt import CRT_SUPPORTED_AUTH_TYPES
from botocore.endpoint_provider import EndpointProvider
from botocore.exceptions import (
EndpointProviderError,
EndpointVariantError,
InvalidEndpointConfigurationError,
InvalidHostLabelError,
MissingDependencyException,
NoRegionError,
ParamValidationError,
UnknownEndpointResolutionBuiltInName,
UnknownRegionError,
UnknownSignatureVersionError,
UnsupportedS3AccesspointConfigurationError,
UnsupportedS3ConfigurationError,
UnsupportedS3ControlArnError,
UnsupportedS3ControlConfigurationError,
)
from botocore.utils import ensure_boolean, instance_cache
LOG = logging.getLogger(__name__)
DEFAULT_URI_TEMPLATE = '{service}.{region}.{dnsSuffix}' # noqa
DEFAULT_SERVICE_DATA = {'endpoints': {}}
class BaseEndpointResolver:
"""Resolves regions and endpoints. Must be subclassed."""
def construct_endpoint(self, service_name, region_name=None):
"""Resolves an endpoint for a service and region combination.
:type service_name: string
:param service_name: Name of the service to resolve an endpoint for
(e.g., s3)
:type region_name: string
:param region_name: Region/endpoint name to resolve (e.g., us-east-1)
if no region is provided, the first found partition-wide endpoint
will be used if available.
:rtype: dict
:return: Returns a dict containing the following keys:
- partition: (string, required) Resolved partition name
- endpointName: (string, required) Resolved endpoint name
- hostname: (string, required) Hostname to use for this endpoint
- sslCommonName: (string) sslCommonName to use for this endpoint.
- credentialScope: (dict) Signature version 4 credential scope
- region: (string) region name override when signing.
- service: (string) service name override when signing.
- signatureVersions: (list<string>) A list of possible signature
versions, including s3, v4, v2, and s3v4
- protocols: (list<string>) A list of supported protocols
(e.g., http, https)
- ...: Other keys may be included as well based on the metadata
"""
raise NotImplementedError
def get_available_partitions(self):
"""Lists the partitions available to the endpoint resolver.
:return: Returns a list of partition names (e.g., ["aws", "aws-cn"]).
"""
raise NotImplementedError
def get_available_endpoints(
self, service_name, partition_name='aws', allow_non_regional=False
):
"""Lists the endpoint names of a particular partition.
:type service_name: string
:param service_name: Name of a service to list endpoint for (e.g., s3)
:type partition_name: string
:param partition_name: Name of the partition to limit endpoints to.
(e.g., aws for the public AWS endpoints, aws-cn for AWS China
endpoints, aws-us-gov for AWS GovCloud (US) Endpoints, etc.
:type allow_non_regional: bool
:param allow_non_regional: Set to True to include endpoints that are
not regional endpoints (e.g., s3-external-1,
fips-us-gov-west-1, etc).
:return: Returns a list of endpoint names (e.g., ["us-east-1"]).
"""
raise NotImplementedError
class EndpointResolver(BaseEndpointResolver):
"""Resolves endpoints based on partition endpoint metadata"""
_UNSUPPORTED_DUALSTACK_PARTITIONS = ['aws-iso', 'aws-iso-b']
def __init__(self, endpoint_data, uses_builtin_data=False):
"""
:type endpoint_data: dict
:param endpoint_data: A dict of partition data.
:type uses_builtin_data: boolean
:param uses_builtin_data: Whether the endpoint data originates in the
package's data directory.
"""
if 'partitions' not in endpoint_data:
raise ValueError('Missing "partitions" in endpoint data')
self._endpoint_data = endpoint_data
self.uses_builtin_data = uses_builtin_data
def get_service_endpoints_data(self, service_name, partition_name='aws'):
for partition in self._endpoint_data['partitions']:
if partition['partition'] != partition_name:
continue
services = partition['services']
if service_name not in services:
continue
return services[service_name]['endpoints']
def get_available_partitions(self):
result = []
for partition in self._endpoint_data['partitions']:
result.append(partition['partition'])
return result
def get_available_endpoints(
self,
service_name,
partition_name='aws',
allow_non_regional=False,
endpoint_variant_tags=None,
):
result = []
for partition in self._endpoint_data['partitions']:
if partition['partition'] != partition_name:
continue
services = partition['services']
if service_name not in services:
continue
service_endpoints = services[service_name]['endpoints']
for endpoint_name in service_endpoints:
is_regional_endpoint = endpoint_name in partition['regions']
# Only regional endpoints can be modeled with variants
if endpoint_variant_tags and is_regional_endpoint:
variant_data = self._retrieve_variant_data(
service_endpoints[endpoint_name], endpoint_variant_tags
)
if variant_data:
result.append(endpoint_name)
elif allow_non_regional or is_regional_endpoint:
result.append(endpoint_name)
return result
def get_partition_dns_suffix(
self, partition_name, endpoint_variant_tags=None
):
for partition in self._endpoint_data['partitions']:
if partition['partition'] == partition_name:
if endpoint_variant_tags:
variant = self._retrieve_variant_data(
partition.get('defaults'), endpoint_variant_tags
)
if variant and 'dnsSuffix' in variant:
return variant['dnsSuffix']
else:
return partition['dnsSuffix']
return None
def construct_endpoint(
self,
service_name,
region_name=None,
partition_name=None,
use_dualstack_endpoint=False,
use_fips_endpoint=False,
):
if (
service_name == 's3'
and use_dualstack_endpoint
and region_name is None
):
region_name = 'us-east-1'
if partition_name is not None:
valid_partition = None
for partition in self._endpoint_data['partitions']:
if partition['partition'] == partition_name:
valid_partition = partition
if valid_partition is not None:
result = self._endpoint_for_partition(
valid_partition,
service_name,
region_name,
use_dualstack_endpoint,
use_fips_endpoint,
True,
)
return result
return None
# Iterate over each partition until a match is found.
for partition in self._endpoint_data['partitions']:
if use_dualstack_endpoint and (
partition['partition']
in self._UNSUPPORTED_DUALSTACK_PARTITIONS
):
continue
result = self._endpoint_for_partition(
partition,
service_name,
region_name,
use_dualstack_endpoint,
use_fips_endpoint,
)
if result:
return result
def get_partition_for_region(self, region_name):
for partition in self._endpoint_data['partitions']:
if self._region_match(partition, region_name):
return partition['partition']
raise UnknownRegionError(
region_name=region_name,
error_msg='No partition found for provided region_name.',
)
def _endpoint_for_partition(
self,
partition,
service_name,
region_name,
use_dualstack_endpoint,
use_fips_endpoint,
force_partition=False,
):
partition_name = partition["partition"]
if (
use_dualstack_endpoint
and partition_name in self._UNSUPPORTED_DUALSTACK_PARTITIONS
):
error_msg = (
"Dualstack endpoints are currently not supported"
" for %s partition" % partition_name
)
raise EndpointVariantError(tags=['dualstack'], error_msg=error_msg)
# Get the service from the partition, or an empty template.
service_data = partition['services'].get(
service_name, DEFAULT_SERVICE_DATA
)
# Use the partition endpoint if no region is supplied.
if region_name is None:
if 'partitionEndpoint' in service_data:
region_name = service_data['partitionEndpoint']
else:
raise NoRegionError()
resolve_kwargs = {
'partition': partition,
'service_name': service_name,
'service_data': service_data,
'endpoint_name': region_name,
'use_dualstack_endpoint': use_dualstack_endpoint,
'use_fips_endpoint': use_fips_endpoint,
}
# Attempt to resolve the exact region for this partition.
if region_name in service_data['endpoints']:
return self._resolve(**resolve_kwargs)
# Check to see if the endpoint provided is valid for the partition.
if self._region_match(partition, region_name) or force_partition:
# Use the partition endpoint if set and not regionalized.
partition_endpoint = service_data.get('partitionEndpoint')
is_regionalized = service_data.get('isRegionalized', True)
if partition_endpoint and not is_regionalized:
LOG.debug(
'Using partition endpoint for %s, %s: %s',
service_name,
region_name,
partition_endpoint,
)
resolve_kwargs['endpoint_name'] = partition_endpoint
return self._resolve(**resolve_kwargs)
LOG.debug(
'Creating a regex based endpoint for %s, %s',
service_name,
region_name,
)
return self._resolve(**resolve_kwargs)
def _region_match(self, partition, region_name):
if region_name in partition['regions']:
return True
if 'regionRegex' in partition:
return re.compile(partition['regionRegex']).match(region_name)
return False
def _retrieve_variant_data(self, endpoint_data, tags):
variants = endpoint_data.get('variants', [])
for variant in variants:
if set(variant['tags']) == set(tags):
result = variant.copy()
return result
def _create_tag_list(self, use_dualstack_endpoint, use_fips_endpoint):
tags = []
if use_dualstack_endpoint:
tags.append('dualstack')
if use_fips_endpoint:
tags.append('fips')
return tags
def _resolve_variant(
self, tags, endpoint_data, service_defaults, partition_defaults
):
result = {}
for variants in [endpoint_data, service_defaults, partition_defaults]:
variant = self._retrieve_variant_data(variants, tags)
if variant:
self._merge_keys(variant, result)
return result
def _resolve(
self,
partition,
service_name,
service_data,
endpoint_name,
use_dualstack_endpoint,
use_fips_endpoint,
):
endpoint_data = service_data.get('endpoints', {}).get(
endpoint_name, {}
)
if endpoint_data.get('deprecated'):
LOG.warning(
'Client is configured with the deprecated endpoint: %s'
% (endpoint_name)
)
service_defaults = service_data.get('defaults', {})
partition_defaults = partition.get('defaults', {})
tags = self._create_tag_list(use_dualstack_endpoint, use_fips_endpoint)
if tags:
result = self._resolve_variant(
tags, endpoint_data, service_defaults, partition_defaults
)
if result == {}:
error_msg = (
f"Endpoint does not exist for {service_name} "
f"in region {endpoint_name}"
)
raise EndpointVariantError(tags=tags, error_msg=error_msg)
self._merge_keys(endpoint_data, result)
else:
result = endpoint_data
# If dnsSuffix has not already been consumed from a variant definition
if 'dnsSuffix' not in result:
result['dnsSuffix'] = partition['dnsSuffix']
result['partition'] = partition['partition']
result['endpointName'] = endpoint_name
# Merge in the service defaults then the partition defaults.
self._merge_keys(service_defaults, result)
self._merge_keys(partition_defaults, result)
result['hostname'] = self._expand_template(
partition,
result['hostname'],
service_name,
endpoint_name,
result['dnsSuffix'],
)
if 'sslCommonName' in result:
result['sslCommonName'] = self._expand_template(
partition,
result['sslCommonName'],
service_name,
endpoint_name,
result['dnsSuffix'],
)
return result
def _merge_keys(self, from_data, result):
for key in from_data:
if key not in result:
result[key] = from_data[key]
def _expand_template(
self, partition, template, service_name, endpoint_name, dnsSuffix
):
return template.format(
service=service_name, region=endpoint_name, dnsSuffix=dnsSuffix
)
class EndpointResolverBuiltins(str, Enum):
# The AWS Region configured for the SDK client (str)
AWS_REGION = "AWS::Region"
# Whether the UseFIPSEndpoint configuration option has been enabled for
# the SDK client (bool)
AWS_USE_FIPS = "AWS::UseFIPS"
# Whether the UseDualStackEndpoint configuration option has been enabled
# for the SDK client (bool)
AWS_USE_DUALSTACK = "AWS::UseDualStack"
# Whether the global endpoint should be used with STS, rather the the
# regional endpoint for us-east-1 (bool)
AWS_STS_USE_GLOBAL_ENDPOINT = "AWS::STS::UseGlobalEndpoint"
# Whether the global endpoint should be used with S3, rather then the
# regional endpoint for us-east-1 (bool)
AWS_S3_USE_GLOBAL_ENDPOINT = "AWS::S3::UseGlobalEndpoint"
# Whether S3 Transfer Acceleration has been requested (bool)
AWS_S3_ACCELERATE = "AWS::S3::Accelerate"
# Whether S3 Force Path Style has been enabled (bool)
AWS_S3_FORCE_PATH_STYLE = "AWS::S3::ForcePathStyle"
# Whether to use the ARN region or raise an error when ARN and client
# region differ (for s3 service only, bool)
AWS_S3_USE_ARN_REGION = "AWS::S3::UseArnRegion"
# Whether to use the ARN region or raise an error when ARN and client
# region differ (for s3-control service only, bool)
AWS_S3CONTROL_USE_ARN_REGION = 'AWS::S3Control::UseArnRegion'
# Whether multi-region access points (MRAP) should be disabled (bool)
AWS_S3_DISABLE_MRAP = "AWS::S3::DisableMultiRegionAccessPoints"
# Whether a custom endpoint has been configured (str)
SDK_ENDPOINT = "SDK::Endpoint"
class EndpointRulesetResolver:
"""Resolves endpoints using a service's endpoint ruleset"""
def __init__(
self,
endpoint_ruleset_data,
partition_data,
service_model,
builtins,
client_context,
event_emitter,
use_ssl=True,
requested_auth_scheme=None,
):
self._provider = EndpointProvider(
ruleset_data=endpoint_ruleset_data,
partition_data=partition_data,
)
self._param_definitions = self._provider.ruleset.parameters
self._service_model = service_model
self._builtins = builtins
self._client_context = client_context
self._event_emitter = event_emitter
self._use_ssl = use_ssl
self._requested_auth_scheme = requested_auth_scheme
self._instance_cache = {}
def construct_endpoint(
self,
operation_model,
call_args,
request_context,
):
"""Invokes the provider with params defined in the service's ruleset"""
if call_args is None:
call_args = {}
if request_context is None:
request_context = {}
provider_params = self._get_provider_params(
operation_model, call_args, request_context
)
LOG.debug(
'Calling endpoint provider with parameters: %s' % provider_params
)
try:
provider_result = self._provider.resolve_endpoint(
**provider_params
)
except EndpointProviderError as ex:
botocore_exception = self.ruleset_error_to_botocore_exception(
ex, provider_params
)
if botocore_exception is None:
raise
else:
raise botocore_exception from ex
LOG.debug('Endpoint provider result: %s' % provider_result.url)
# The endpoint provider does not support non-secure transport.
if not self._use_ssl and provider_result.url.startswith('https://'):
provider_result = provider_result._replace(
url=f'http://{provider_result.url[8:]}'
)
# Multi-valued headers are not supported in botocore. Replace the list
# of values returned for each header with just its first entry,
# dropping any additionally entries.
provider_result = provider_result._replace(
headers={
key: val[0] for key, val in provider_result.headers.items()
}
)
return provider_result
def _get_provider_params(
self, operation_model, call_args, request_context
):
"""Resolve a value for each parameter defined in the service's ruleset
The resolution order for parameter values is:
1. Operation-specific static context values from the service definition
2. Operation-specific dynamic context values from API parameters
3. Client-specific context parameters
4. Built-in values such as region, FIPS usage, ...
"""
provider_params = {}
# Builtin values can be customized for each operation by hooks
# subscribing to the ``before-endpoint-resolution.*`` event.
customized_builtins = self._get_customized_builtins(
operation_model, call_args, request_context
)
for param_name, param_def in self._param_definitions.items():
param_val = self._resolve_param_from_context(
param_name=param_name,
operation_model=operation_model,
call_args=call_args,
)
if param_val is None and param_def.builtin is not None:
param_val = self._resolve_param_as_builtin(
builtin_name=param_def.builtin,
builtins=customized_builtins,
)
if param_val is not None:
provider_params[param_name] = param_val
return provider_params
def _resolve_param_from_context(
self, param_name, operation_model, call_args
):
static = self._resolve_param_as_static_context_param(
param_name, operation_model
)
if static is not None:
return static
dynamic = self._resolve_param_as_dynamic_context_param(
param_name, operation_model, call_args
)
if dynamic is not None:
return dynamic
return self._resolve_param_as_client_context_param(param_name)
def _resolve_param_as_static_context_param(
self, param_name, operation_model
):
static_ctx_params = self._get_static_context_params(operation_model)
return static_ctx_params.get(param_name)
def _resolve_param_as_dynamic_context_param(
self, param_name, operation_model, call_args
):
dynamic_ctx_params = self._get_dynamic_context_params(operation_model)
if param_name in dynamic_ctx_params:
member_name = dynamic_ctx_params[param_name]
return call_args.get(member_name)
def _resolve_param_as_client_context_param(self, param_name):
client_ctx_params = self._get_client_context_params()
if param_name in client_ctx_params:
client_ctx_varname = client_ctx_params[param_name]
return self._client_context.get(client_ctx_varname)
def _resolve_param_as_builtin(self, builtin_name, builtins):
if builtin_name not in EndpointResolverBuiltins.__members__.values():
raise UnknownEndpointResolutionBuiltInName(name=builtin_name)
return builtins.get(builtin_name)
@instance_cache
def _get_static_context_params(self, operation_model):
"""Mapping of param names to static param value for an operation"""
return {
param.name: param.value
for param in operation_model.static_context_parameters
}
@instance_cache
def _get_dynamic_context_params(self, operation_model):
"""Mapping of param names to member names for an operation"""
return {
param.name: param.member_name
for param in operation_model.context_parameters
}
@instance_cache
def _get_client_context_params(self):
"""Mapping of param names to client configuration variable"""
return {
param.name: xform_name(param.name)
for param in self._service_model.client_context_parameters
}
def _get_customized_builtins(
self, operation_model, call_args, request_context
):
service_id = self._service_model.service_id.hyphenize()
customized_builtins = copy.copy(self._builtins)
# Handlers are expected to modify the builtins dict in place.
self._event_emitter.emit(
'before-endpoint-resolution.%s' % service_id,
builtins=customized_builtins,
model=operation_model,
params=call_args,
context=request_context,
)
return customized_builtins
def auth_schemes_to_signing_ctx(self, auth_schemes):
"""Convert an Endpoint's authSchemes property to a signing_context dict
:type auth_schemes: list
:param auth_schemes: A list of dictionaries taken from the
``authSchemes`` property of an Endpoint object returned by
``EndpointProvider``.
:rtype: str, dict
:return: Tuple of auth type string (to be used in
``request_context['auth_type']``) and signing context dict (for use
in ``request_context['signing']``).
"""
if not isinstance(auth_schemes, list) or len(auth_schemes) == 0:
raise TypeError("auth_schemes must be a non-empty list.")
LOG.debug(
'Selecting from endpoint provider\'s list of auth schemes: %s. '
'User selected auth scheme is: "%s"',
', '.join([f'"{s.get("name")}"' for s in auth_schemes]),
self._requested_auth_scheme,
)
if self._requested_auth_scheme == UNSIGNED:
return 'none', {}
auth_schemes = [
{**scheme, 'name': self._strip_sig_prefix(scheme['name'])}
for scheme in auth_schemes
]
if self._requested_auth_scheme is not None:
try:
# Use the first scheme that matches the requested scheme,
# after accounting for naming differences between botocore and
# endpoint rulesets. Keep the requested name.
name, scheme = next(
(self._requested_auth_scheme, s)
for s in auth_schemes
if self._does_botocore_authname_match_ruleset_authname(
self._requested_auth_scheme, s['name']
)
)
except StopIteration:
# For legacy signers, no match will be found. Do not raise an
# exception, instead default to the logic in botocore
# customizations.
return None, {}
else:
try:
name, scheme = next(
(s['name'], s)
for s in auth_schemes
if s['name'] in AUTH_TYPE_MAPS
)
except StopIteration:
# If no auth scheme was specifically requested and an
# authSchemes list is present in the Endpoint object but none
# of the entries are supported, raise an exception.
fixable_with_crt = False
auth_type_options = [s['name'] for s in auth_schemes]
if not HAS_CRT:
fixable_with_crt = any(
scheme in CRT_SUPPORTED_AUTH_TYPES
for scheme in auth_type_options
)
if fixable_with_crt:
raise MissingDependencyException(
msg='This operation requires an additional dependency.'
' Use pip install botocore[crt] before proceeding.'
)
else:
raise UnknownSignatureVersionError(
signature_version=', '.join(auth_type_options)
)
signing_context = {}
if 'signingRegion' in scheme:
signing_context['region'] = scheme['signingRegion']
elif 'signingRegionSet' in scheme:
if len(scheme['signingRegionSet']) > 0:
signing_context['region'] = scheme['signingRegionSet'][0]
if 'signingName' in scheme:
signing_context.update(signing_name=scheme['signingName'])
if 'disableDoubleEncoding' in scheme:
signing_context['disableDoubleEncoding'] = ensure_boolean(
scheme['disableDoubleEncoding']
)
LOG.debug(
'Selected auth type "%s" as "%s" with signing context params: %s',
scheme['name'], # original name without "sig"
name, # chosen name can differ when `signature_version` is set
signing_context,
)
return name, signing_context
def _strip_sig_prefix(self, auth_name):
"""Normalize auth type names by removing any "sig" prefix"""
return auth_name[3:] if auth_name.startswith('sig') else auth_name
def _does_botocore_authname_match_ruleset_authname(self, botoname, rsname):
"""
Whether a valid string provided as signature_version parameter for
client construction refers to the same auth methods as a string
returned by the endpoint ruleset provider. This accounts for:
* The ruleset prefixes auth names with "sig"
* The s3 and s3control rulesets don't distinguish between v4[a] and
s3v4[a] signers
* The v2, v3, and HMAC v1 based signers (s3, s3-*) are botocore legacy
features and do not exist in the rulesets
* Only characters up to the first dash are considered
Example matches:
* v4, sigv4
* v4, v4
* s3v4, sigv4
* s3v7, sigv7 (hypothetical example)
* s3v4a, sigv4a
* s3v4-query, sigv4
Example mismatches:
* v4a, sigv4
* s3, sigv4
* s3-presign-post, sigv4
"""
rsname = self._strip_sig_prefix(rsname)
botoname = botoname.split('-')[0]
if botoname != 's3' and botoname.startswith('s3'):
botoname = botoname[2:]
return rsname == botoname
def ruleset_error_to_botocore_exception(self, ruleset_exception, params):
"""Attempts to translate ruleset errors to pre-existing botocore
exception types by string matching exception strings.
"""
msg = ruleset_exception.kwargs.get('msg')
if msg is None:
return
if msg.startswith('Invalid region in ARN: '):
# Example message:
# "Invalid region in ARN: `us-we$t-2` (invalid DNS name)"
try:
label = msg.split('`')[1]
except IndexError:
label = msg
return InvalidHostLabelError(label=label)
service_name = self._service_model.service_name
if service_name == 's3':
if (
msg == 'S3 Object Lambda does not support S3 Accelerate'
or msg == 'Accelerate cannot be used with FIPS'
):
return UnsupportedS3ConfigurationError(msg=msg)
if (
msg.startswith('S3 Outposts does not support')
or msg.startswith('S3 MRAP does not support')
or msg.startswith('S3 Object Lambda does not support')
or msg.startswith('Access Points do not support')
or msg.startswith('Invalid configuration:')
or msg.startswith('Client was configured for partition')
):
return UnsupportedS3AccesspointConfigurationError(msg=msg)
if msg.lower().startswith('invalid arn:'):
return ParamValidationError(report=msg)
if service_name == 's3control':
if msg.startswith('Invalid ARN:'):
arn = params.get('Bucket')
return UnsupportedS3ControlArnError(arn=arn, msg=msg)
if msg.startswith('Invalid configuration:') or msg.startswith(
'Client was configured for partition'
):
return UnsupportedS3ControlConfigurationError(msg=msg)
if msg == "AccountId is required but not set":
return ParamValidationError(report=msg)
if service_name == 'events':
if msg.startswith(
'Invalid Configuration: FIPS is not supported with '
'EventBridge multi-region endpoints.'
):
return InvalidEndpointConfigurationError(msg=msg)
if msg == 'EndpointId must be a valid host label.':
return InvalidEndpointConfigurationError(msg=msg)
return None

Powered by BW's shoe-string budget.